Skip to main content
Select a menu in the customizer

The Impact of Religion on Politics

How Religion Affects Politics

According to conventional wisdom, religion affects politics. However, scholars have developed a different view. They define religion as whatever dominant concern serves to organize a person’s values and create a doctrine that supports it.

This definition suggests that it is not a universal phenomenon and that religions vary in their influence on politics. For example, Democrats may pull away from religion because they associate it with Republicans and conservative politics.

Religion is a social genus

The idea that religion is a social genus has become controversial among anthropologists. Some have criticized the notion that religion is a concept invented by humans, and others have argued that it has no objective meaning. They argue that thinking of religion as a mental state is a Protestant bias and that scholars should instead focus on social structures and discipline techniques rather than inner states.

A political-religious cleavage can be dangerous, especially when it is used to legitimize unequal power relations. For example, when religious churches backed the mill owners during a strike in 1912, they weakened the movement and contributed to the failure of the strike. Politicians who employ religion must be aware of the risks, or they may lose voters. A strong warning sign is if voters refuse to vote for, contribute to, or campaign for politicians who use religion. This will quickly prompt them to change their position.

Religion is a social group

Religion can help alleviate poverty and promote social justice, but it can also reinforce inequality and fuel conflict. This is partly why Marx called religion “the opium of the masses.” By focusing on eternal life and spiritual comfort, religion can distract people from their exploitation and prevent them from recognizing that existing social relations are distorted.

Political scientists such as Michele Margolis have used this conflict perspective to examine how religion affects politics. Her research finds that partisanship influences how religious people make decisions about their religiosity. Margolis has also found that people who vote for a Republican candidate are less likely to say they are religious.

This is because they place party over principle. If voters snub politicians who use religion, the latter will quickly change their tactics. This is especially true if the politician’s base supports them. For example, in the 1960 election, Catholic religiosity was tied to John F. Kennedy. The findings in this study are based on an analysis of national surveys and a longitudinal panel dataset.

Religion is a social identity

Religion is a social identity, which means it can be influenced by social structures. This can lead to different outcomes in politics, for example, when the political party in power tries to appeal to religious voters. This may lead to a negative reaction in those who don’t identify as religious, and this can backfire.

Prothero believes that this entanglement of religion and politics is a result of America’s history of religious freedom. The lack of an official state church allows for a more robust religious community, which can be used to influence the political process in times of change. This can be seen in movements like the abolition and civil rights movement.

Some scholars have criticized the notion of religion as a social identity, arguing that it focuses on hidden mental states and does not take into account material realities. Nonetheless, it is important to recognize that the role of religion in society is complex and varied.

Religion is a social practice

Religion is a social practice that involves adopting a concern, constructing a theory of its actual reality, and practicing a doctrine about how to effect a good outcome. This is often accompanied by a sense of obligation to a group and a desire to be part of a transcendental structure. Some religious practices grow into a denomination and others develop into a sect. Sects are breakaway groups that claim to have returned to “the fundamentals” or to contest the veracity of a doctrine.

Politics has a profound impact on religiosity. As political identities become more and more polarized, religion is losing its power to shape Americans’ worldviews. For example, many evangelicals were slow to support Donald Trump, as his business dealings and extramarital affairs contradicted their core beliefs. The only way to counter this trend is for voters to snub politicians who exploit religious faith. This would send a strong message that religious belief and practice are not something to be politicized.

Go to the details